Environmental Impact: Concepts and Foundations
1. Environmental impact
Impact and impacte are used here synonymously: an impact is a strong effect caused by something or someone.
Environment refers to the physical conditions that affect the growth, development and maintenance of an individual, population or community. It can also include the social and cultural conditions affecting them, as well as the surroundings of an inanimate object of intrinsic social value.
Environmental impact is the set of changes caused by humans in the environment of a given area that affect, directly or indirectly, population well-being and the quality of environmental resources.
Impacts may arise from natural events, climate change, human-caused disasters, human activities or development projects. They can affect several dimensions:
| Dimension | Examples |
|---|---|
| Ecological | Air and water quality, radiation levels, flora, fauna, biodiversity, soil erosion and water resources |
| Social | Employment, land use, recreation, cultural and historical features |
| Economic | Infrastructure, consumption, market prices, and labour supply and demand |
2. Environmental monitoring
Environmental monitoring is the continuous observation of one or more environmental descriptors in a defined spatial unit. It tracks change over time, measures temporal variability, and helps detect trends and their main causes.
Monitoring programmes may be:
| Type | Purpose |
|---|---|
| Specific-scope monitoring | Track changes in areas exposed to a defined human activity or other change agent |
| General-scope monitoring | Follow natural variation to improve understanding of environmental dynamics |
Specific-scope monitoring usually has two phases: baseline monitoring, before the action begins, and impact monitoring, after it begins. Although the term became more widely used after the 1972 Stockholm Conference, long-term meteorological and oceanographic monitoring records predate the 20th century.
3. Development and sustainability
Development was traditionally associated with technological and economic progress in human societies. In the 1980s, the concepts of sustainable development and sustainability emerged in response to growing recognition that persistent global problems could pose serious future threats.
4. Environmental Impact Assessment
Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) examines the likely environmental effects of proposed actions and informs decisions about projects. The course covers the assessment process, including screening, scoping, environmental studies, baseline conditions, impact assessment, mitigation and compensation, alternatives, public consultation, decisions and post-assessment.
Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA) is also part of the course, alongside EIA legislation, practice in Portugal and other countries, environmental indicators, and impacts associated with different project types.
Natural Variability and the History of Human Environmental Impacts
1. Natural variability and ecosystem complexity
Ecosystems change naturally, even over short periods, and show substantial temporal and spatial variability. Natural biological systems are structurally complex and closely interconnected with one another and their surroundings, making them readily modified.
Earth is about 4.5–4.6 billion years old and has undergone profound change throughout its history. Life has existed for approximately 4.0–3.5 billion years; biological systems have also changed repeatedly and will continue to do so. About 99.99% of all species that have existed are extinct, and a complex species lasts around 4 million years on average.
| Climate driver | Main timescale or influence |
|---|---|
| Plate tectonics | Long timescales |
| Astronomical cycles (Milankovitch cycles) | Medium timescales |
| Solar activity | Long and short timescales |
| Volcanic eruptions | Episodic |
| Ocean circulation | Regional |
| Biotic activity, including humans | Human influence is relatively recent |
Climate is also shaped by continental positions and areas, mountain formation, and other features of Earth’s surface. Its long-term trends include shorter-term variations.
Natural change is an inherent feature of Earth’s climate and ecosystems; assessing human impacts therefore requires distinguishing them from this background variability.
2. Human environmental impact: origins and evolution
Human presence is very recent in the history of life: the first hominins appeared about 5–7 million years ago, while modern humans (Homo sapiens) are probably more than 300,000 years old. Human origins and diversification are associated with Africa, including the East African Rift system.
The origin of Homo sapiens is not necessarily attributable to one isolated region or population. Evidence supports a model of subdivided African populations linked by occasional gene flow, with ecological boundary changes helping shape their structure.
Human populations also interbred with other archaic human groups:
| Population or ancestry | Approximate genetic contribution reported in the course |
|---|---|
| Archaic forms in sub-Saharan African populations | 2–7% introgression |
| Neanderthal ancestry in Europeans and Asians | About 2% |
| Additional Denisovan ancestry in Asians and Melanesians | More than 3%; up to 6% in Melanesians |
| Neanderthal material in modern African genomes | About 0.3% |
Modern humans have distinctive traits involving brain size, upright posture and bipedalism, skin and heat diffusion, hands, face and vision, jaw and teeth, the throat and larynx, sexual dimorphism, neoteny, and delayed sexual maturation. Increased intelligence enabled humans to simulate possible scenarios and reduced their dependence on genetic constraints.
3. Dispersal and changing environmental influence
The course identifies three main dispersals out of Africa: Homo erectus more than 2 million years ago, Homo heidelbergensis around 600,000 years ago, and Homo sapiens around 200,000 years ago; many other movements probably occurred. Dispersals were likely favored by suitable climate, high population density, and corridors of sparse vegetation.
The view that modern humans left Africa only 60,000–70,000 years ago and simply replaced all Indigenous populations without interbreeding is no longer considered adequate. Earlier dispersals, contractions, extirpations, and extinctions occurred; some dispersals were not evolutionary dead ends. Earlier migrations, beginning around 200,000 years ago, were confined to warmer regions. Leaving Africa also exposed humans to different disease and climate conditions.
Until about 50,000 years ago, human activity was not greatly different from that of other animals, and hunting was largely directed at easy, relatively safe prey. The emergence of modern language may have enabled better communication and social organization, alongside technological development; whether this was a rapid “Great Leap Forward” or a more gradual change remains debated.
More effective tools expanded human impacts on wildlife and ecosystems. Multi-part weapons such as harpoons, spear-throwers, and occasionally bows and arrows enabled hunting at a safer distance, including of dangerous animals such as rhinoceroses and elephants. Cordage, nets, fishing lines, and traps also brought fish and birds into the human diet.
Contemporary Environmental Challenges and Sustainability
1. The long history of human environmental impacts
Human impacts on the environment have increased as human populations have spread and acquired new capabilities. Major forms of impact include habitat alteration (for example, through fire and mining), species extinction (through hunting and competition), species translocation (through introductions), and population growth.
a) Early extinctions
As humans entered new regions, other human species disappeared. Possible causes include competition, conflict, disease, population dilution, climate change, volcanism and other environmental pressures. The disappearance of these groups also reduced the potential human genetic reservoir.
The arrival of humans was also followed by the extinction of many large animals. In Australia, 23 of 24 animal species weighing at least 50 kg disappeared within a few thousand years; food webs were disrupted and reorganized. Similar large-mammal extinctions occurred in Europe, the Americas and on islands. In western America, mass extinctions occurred around 17–12 ka.
Climate change, disease and other factors may have contributed, but human hunting and competition are considered major causes. Outside Africa and Eurasia, many animals had not co-evolved with humans and therefore did not fear them. The use of fire added another source of pressure, especially in Australia. The more recent the event, the faster the impacts tended to be, reflecting growing human capabilities.
2. Agriculture and landscape transformation
The transition to settled farming and herding transformed human relationships with the environment. It could be driven by food shortages, overexploitation of wild resources, climate change or population pressure. Different communities adopted hunting and gathering, pastoralism, agriculture, or combinations of these practices.
Agriculture and livestock farming altered landscapes on a much greater scale than earlier human activities:
- Forests were cleared or burned to create fields and pastures.
- Natural communities became simpler, while exposed soils were eroded by wind and water.
- Irrigated fields could become saline and infertile.
- Forest removal and decomposition, rice cultivation and expanding herds contributed to warming.
- Domestication of livestock also created opportunities for the emergence of new diseases.
The spread of agriculture did not produce the same impact everywhere. In Europe, farming communities from the Middle East entered via Anatolia from about 8.5 ka. Their gradual, incomplete mixture with local hunter-gatherers allowed both ways of life to coexist; environmental change remained mostly local and moderate. A later migration, around 5 ka, brought populations associated with the Yamna culture from the Pontic-Caspian steppe. Their more rapid integration was followed by agriculture becoming dominant and extensive transformation of European vegetation.
3. Early industry, trade and urban growth
The development of metalworking and trade increased environmental pressures through smelting emissions, the movement of people, plants and animals, and population growth in towns. Copper technology dates to approximately 5.3–3.2 ka and bronze technology to 5.3–2.7 ka. Bronze is an alloy of copper and tin, typically in a 10:1 proportion; the limited availability of metals, especially tin, encouraged long-distance exchange.
Air pollution is not only a modern problem. Smoke from domestic wood-burning caused respiratory problems in ancient Egypt and Rome, and Roman courts received complaints about smoke pollution around 2 ka. London had severe air pollution nearly 1 ka ago, associated with burning wood and coal for domestic and industrial uses.
Urban concentration also facilitated disease transmission, while inadequate food quantity and quality contributed to mortality and debility. The Justinian Plague (541–549) caused an estimated 25–100 million deaths. The Black Death (1347–1351) caused an estimated 75–200 million deaths, or 30–60% of Europe’s population.
4. Deforestation
Agricultural expansion and forest clearance substantially reduced European forest cover. Between 500 and 1350, forests declined from covering around 80% of western and central Europe to about half. In France, forest area fell from an estimated 30 million hectares to 13 million hectares between 800 and 1300. In Germany, forests covered 70% of the territory around 900, compared with 25% in 1900. In the Americas, large-scale deforestation accelerated after European colonization, especially from the 18th century.
5. Population expansion and genetic diversity
Human population expansion into new regions often occurred through small groups leaving larger parent populations. Each new founder group carried only part of the parent population’s genetic diversity; repeated settlement therefore reduced diversity farther from the source.
Human populations in Africa had accumulated high genetic diversity over more than 4 million years of evolution, population isolation and interbreeding. Migration out of Africa reduced diversity in newly settled regions, with the reduction generally increasing with distance from the source.
Strategic Environmental Assessment and Environmental Impact Assessment
1. Historical drivers of environmental impact
Human environmental impacts accelerated with globalisation and the Industrial Revolution. The expansion of European maritime trade increased population movements and the exchange of foods, species and pathogens between continents. These exchanges profoundly changed ecosystems; introduced diseases were a major cause of death among Indigenous peoples in the Americas.
The Industrial Revolution replaced hand tools and human or animal power with machinery and motive power, and domestic production with the factory system. It also greatly increased humanity’s impact on the environment.
| Period | Main developments |
|---|---|
| 1760–1850 | Industrialisation was concentrated in England, the “workshop of the world”. |
| 1850–1900 | It spread across Europe, the Americas and Asia; production industries expanded, new energy sources emerged, and steam locomotives and ships transformed transport. |
| 1900 onwards | Industrial conglomerates and multinational companies grew; production became automated and mass-produced, alongside mass consumer society, chemical and electronic industries, genetic engineering and robotics. |
Initially, industrialisation worsened workers’ living conditions and health and degraded urban environments. Later scientific, technological, medical and public-health advances—including vaccines and antibiotics—helped improve living conditions and enabled rapid population growth.
2. Environmental sustainability and societal collapse
A society’s collapse may result from conflict with other societies, climatic or environmental change, or unsustainable practices within the society itself. These causes can combine.
| Case | Key lesson |
|---|---|
| Viking settlements in North America and Greenland | A way of life poorly adapted to local conditions, combined with limited willingness to learn from Indigenous Inuit knowledge, contributed to failure. North American settlements lasted less than a decade. |
| Easter Island | Resource depletion transformed the food base: the island had 21 tree species around AD 900 and none by 1700. At its peak, around 1400, its population was 15,000. |
| Anasazi | Collapse was associated with both resource exhaustion and climatic change. |
| Haiti and the Dominican Republic | Despite sharing an island, different environmental practices contributed to markedly different development outcomes. |
| Medieval Japan | Strict forest policies helped address a severe deforestation crisis. |
| Tikopia | A sustainable society persisted for 3,000 years on an island of less than 5 km², using taboos and practices to limit resource access and population size. |
Environmental collapse is often driven by interacting factors: ecological pressures, climate change and social choices.
3. Quantitative details from the historical cases
- The course estimates that colonisation caused the deaths of about 120 million Indigenous people: 70 million in the Americas and 50 million in Africa and Asia.
- The Atlantic slave trade lasted about four centuries (15th–19th centuries) and involved 16 million deaths and 10–12 million people displaced. The Arab slave trade lasted about 13 centuries (7th–20th centuries) and involved 18.5 million deaths and 12–14 million people displaced.
- The course states that three out of every five captured enslaved people died before reaching their destination. These figures illustrate the immense human and social impacts of the trades.
The EIA Process and Its Stages
1. The EIA process and its stages
An Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) is a structured process for identifying and assessing the likely environmental effects of a proposed project before decisions are made. It helps decision-makers avoid or reduce harmful impacts and informs the public about the project and its consequences.
| Stage | Main purpose and output |
|---|---|
| 1. Screening | Decide whether the project requires an EIA, considering its type, scale, location and likely impacts. |
| 2. Scoping | Identify the important issues to assess, the study boundaries and the information required. |
| 3. Baseline study | Describe existing environmental conditions, providing a reference against which future changes can be assessed. |
| 4. Impact assessment | Predict and evaluate likely effects, including their magnitude, extent, duration and significance. |
| 5. Mitigation and alternatives | Compare feasible alternatives and propose measures to avoid, reduce or remedy adverse impacts. |
| 6. Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) | Present the assessment, evidence, alternatives and mitigation measures in a report for review. |
| 7. Review and decision-making | Check the quality and completeness of the EIS; authorities use it, alongside other relevant considerations, to decide whether and under what conditions the project can proceed. |
| 8. Follow-up | Monitor actual impacts and the effectiveness of mitigation, and take corrective action where needed. |
2. Key assessment principles
The assessment compares the project’s likely effects with the baseline environment and considers both adverse and beneficial impacts. It should consider relevant environmental components and how impacts may interact.
The mitigation hierarchy is to avoid impacts where possible, minimise those that cannot be avoided, and remedy or compensate for remaining effects.
Remember: EIA is carried out before a project decision so that environmental information can influence the choice, design and conditions of the project.
Portuguese EIA Legislation and Practice
1. Environmental assessment: two complementary instruments
| Instrument | Object of assessment | Main purpose |
|---|---|---|
| Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA; AAE) | Plans, programmes and policies | Integrate environmental, social and economic considerations into planning; identify impacts and compare alternatives while they are still under discussion. |
| Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA; AIA) | Development projects | Predict a project’s environmental effects, identify measures to avoid, minimise or compensate for them, and inform the decision on whether it may proceed. |
SEA can apply to sectoral and spatial plans, regional development programmes, natural-resource strategies, policies, proposed legislation, investment operations, privatisations and international treaties. EIA is a preventive environmental-policy instrument, based on studies, consultation, public participation and analysis of alternatives.
2. Why EIA matters
Current environmental pressures include population growth, excessive and unequal consumption, shortages of food, water, energy and raw materials, biodiversity loss, environmental degradation and irreversible climate change. EIA helps bring environmental considerations into decisions about development before a project is approved.
EIA aims to give decision-makers information about significant environmental implications and to suggest changes that eliminate potential adverse impacts, enhance positive ones and minimise unavoidable effects. Assessment should be integrated, considering physical, biological and socioeconomic effects rather than treating them separately.
EIA informs decisions; it is not itself an environmental protection measure.
3. Development-project stages
| Project stage | Typical phase |
|---|---|
| Planning | Preliminary design and detailed design |
| Implementation | Construction or installation |
| Operation | Functioning or exploitation |
| Closure | Decommissioning |
EIA is a continuous process: it should begin as soon as an action is proposed, inform planning and design, and continue through operation and abandonment, including attention to impacts after closure.
4. Main stages of the EIA process
- Screening: determine whether the proposed action requires EIA.
- Scoping: identify the relevant environmental issues and factors to be assessed.
- Environmental Impact Study (EIS; EIA report): establish baseline conditions and predict impacts.
- Review and consultation: assess the study and other documents, consider opinions and the public-consultation report, and prepare a proposed environmental impact statement.
- Decision: decide on the project’s viability.
- Post-assessment: carry out environmental monitoring, audits and enforcement.
Screening is necessary because EIA requires significant technical and financial resources; not every proposed action can be assessed in the same way. The screening decision takes account of the project type and characteristics, including its size and location.
5. Historical milestones
| Date / period | Milestone |
|---|---|
| Late 1960s | Growing environmental crisis and concern about the worsening relationship between human and natural systems. |
| 1969 | The United States’ National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) establishes the first formal EIA framework and the principle that environmental factors should be explicitly considered in decision-making. |
| 1972 | United Nations Conference on the Human Environment, Stockholm. |
| 1983 | Commission for Sustainable Development established. |
| 1985 | European Community Directive 85/337/EEC makes EIA of projects a Community requirement. |
| 1987 | Brundtland Report. |
| 1990 | Portugal applies Community EIA legislation through Decree-Law 186/90, which regulates and establishes EIA. |
| 1991 | Espoo Convention on environmental impact assessment in a transboundary context concluded on 25 February; transposed in Portugal by Decree-Law 59/99. |
| 1992 | Earth Summit, Rio de Janeiro. |
| 1997 | Directive 97/11/EC, dated 3 March, amends Directive 85/337/EEC. |
| 2000 onward | Portuguese framework includes Decree-Law 69/2000, Ministerial Order 329/2001, Decree-Law 197/2005 and Rectification Declaration 2/2006. |
| 2002 | Earth Summit, Johannesburg. |
In Portugal, environmental assessment initially focused on economic efficiency and cost-benefit analysis until the 1970s. Its importance grew from the 1970s to 1985; after the Community requirement was introduced, national transposition was delayed. The Environment Framework Law 11/87 described EIA as a fundamental preventive instrument of environmental and spatial-planning policy, supporting sustainable development through balanced natural-resource management and protection of environmental quality.
6. EIA principles
EIA provides information on the potential environmental impacts of proposed development. It enables decision-makers to consider development alternatives, the wider context of environmental resources and policy, and methods for reducing impacts and their associated costs. It can also provide a consultation mechanism and a framework for agreement between project proponents and affected parties.
EIA has evolved from a legal requirement into a multidisciplinary, integrated assessment that considers environmental, economic and technical components, while leaving the final decision to the political decision-making process.
Environmental Impact Studies: Structure and Baseline Assessment
1. Screening: selecting projects for EIA
Projects may be selected for Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) using three approaches:
| Method | How projects are selected |
|---|---|
| Case-by-case | Each project is assessed individually. |
| Lists | Positive lists identify projects requiring EIA; negative or exclusion lists identify projects exempt from it. Lists may set thresholds to define which projects are covered. |
| Mixed characteristics | Selection combines project characteristics and other criteria. |
Selection should consider not only project features, such as capacity, but also the sensitivity of the project location.
2. Scoping
Scoping is an early, preliminary stage that identifies and selects the significant environmental issues an EIA should address. It helps focus the assessment, plan the EIA and establish its terms of reference. In Portugal, scoping is optional; when undertaken, the developer prepares a scoping proposal (PDA), which is assessed by the EIA Authority.
Scoping supports the quality and relevance of the EIA, encourages early involvement of authorities and interested groups, helps reduce potential conflicts, and facilitates decision-making.
| Scoping task | Key points |
|---|---|
| Identify | Main environmental issues, potentially affected environmental factors, and stakeholders |
| Define | The EIA’s boundaries, study area, and realistic alternatives |
| Plan | Assessment methods, public and stakeholder engagement, and the studies to be carried out |
| Specify | Terms of reference, including mitigation, monitoring, required information, and the EIA timetable |
Those involved may include the developer, licensing authority, EIA Authority, other public bodies, consultants and experts, stakeholders (including people affected by the project), and the public.
3. Environmental Impact Statement (EIS)
The Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) is a document prepared during the EIA process. It briefly describes the project, presents baseline environmental information, and assesses and discusses relevant likely positive and negative impacts.
It should give decision-makers and other involved parties usable information about the project’s environmental implications, the significance of impacts, mitigation measures, alternatives, and associated costs. The EIS should be prepared early in project development, especially at the preliminary or outline-design stage; in Portugal, preparation is the developer’s responsibility.
The Non-Technical Summary (NTS) presents the EIS in non-technical language and is important for public participation.
4. EIS review and decision
An EIS may be reviewed by an independent consultant, an independent expert committee, or the institution administering the EIA process. The review checks whether the EIS follows applicable guidelines and legislation, is understandable to non-specialists, and provides an adequate basis for decision-making. Public consultation documentation is also submitted to the decision-making authority.
| Review outcome | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Non-compliance | The EIS is not of sufficient quality to support a decision. |
| Reformulation | Further studies or clarification are needed because of uncertainty or gaps. |
| Decision possible | The authority can decide whether to approve or reject the project. |
The purpose of the decision stage is to approve or reject the project and, if approved, set conditions for its implementation. In Portugal, the environmental decision is the Environmental Impact Statement (DIA) and is binding. It may be favourable, conditionally favourable, or unfavourable.
5. Post-assessment: monitoring and audits
Post-assessment takes place after the DIA. It checks compliance with its conditions and evaluates impacts during construction, operation, and decommissioning, as well as the effectiveness of environmental management measures. Additional measures may be adopted if needed.
| Activity | Definition and purpose |
|---|---|
| Environmental monitoring | Systematic observation and data collection on environmental conditions or project effects, reported periodically to assess whether measures to avoid, minimise, or compensate for significant impacts are effective. |
| Environmental audit | A retrospective assessment of project impacts against environmental quality standards, impact predictions, management measures, and EIA recommendations. |
6. Public participation
Public participation is an essential part of the EIA procedure: it ensures that interested members of the public can contribute to decision-making. Public consultation is the process for collecting their opinions, suggestions, and other contributions on a project subject to EIA.
7. Portuguese EIA legislation and key terms
The Portuguese framework is based on Decree-Law 151-B/2013, as amended by:
- Decree-Law 47/2014, 24 March;
- Decree-Law 179/2015, 27 August;
- Law 37/2017, 2 June;
- Decree-Law 152-B/2017, 11 December;
- Decree-Law 102-D/2020, 10 December;
- Decree-Law 11/2023, 10 February (Simplex Ambiental).
It is complemented, among other legislation, by Ordinance 395/2015, and transposes Directive 2011/92/EU and Directive 2014/52/EU.
| Term | Meaning under Portuguese legislation |
|---|---|
| Project | Construction works or other installations, works, or interventions in the natural environment or landscape, including those intended to exploit natural resources. |
| Developer | A natural or legal person, public or private, applying for authorisation or a licence for a project. |
| Public | One or more individuals or public- or private-law entities, including their associations, representative organisations, or groups. |
| Sensitive areas | Protected areas; Natura 2000 sites, special areas of conservation, and special protection areas; and protection zones for classified or proposed-to-be-classified immovable property. |
| DIA | An express or tacit decision on a project’s environmental viability, at preliminary study, outline-design, or execution-project stage. |
| Authorisation or licence | A decision granting the developer the right to carry out the project. |
Under Portuguese law, Annex I projects are always subject to EIA. Annex II projects are subject to EIA according to their size and/or location.
Impact Identification, Assessment and Methodologies
1. Purpose and scope of an Environmental Impact Assessment
An Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) identifies and evaluates all significant positive and negative impacts of a project. It supports the selection of the best alternative and proposes measures to avoid, minimise or compensate for negative impacts, and to enhance positive ones.
The EIA is the proponent’s responsibility and should begin early in project development, especially at the preliminary-design or draft-project stage.
2. Main phases of the EIA process
| Phase | Main purpose |
|---|---|
| Screening | Decide whether an EIA is required and identify the actions subject to assessment. |
| Scoping | Define the assessment’s scope and the issues to be studied. |
| Baseline studies | Describe the existing environment and its likely evolution without the project. |
| Impact assessment | Identify and evaluate significant impacts and consider alternatives and mitigation. |
| EIA report and review | Present the findings and assess the report’s adequacy. |
| Decision and implementation | Approve, conditionally approve or reject the project; implement applicable measures. |
| Monitoring and post-assessment | Check compliance and assess the effectiveness of the assessment and its measures. |
3. EIA report
The EIA generally comprises a Non-Technical Summary (NTS), a main report or synthesis report, technical reports where needed, and annexes. Its contents include:
- Introduction and project objectives and justification.
- Project description and alternatives considered.
- Description of the affected environment.
- Environmental impacts and mitigation or enhancement measures.
- Monitoring and environmental management measures.
- Technical or knowledge gaps.
- Conclusions.
a) Non-Technical Summary
The NTS is a mandatory, separate document that summarises the EIA in accessible language for the general public. It supports meaningful public participation and should be concise, clear, rigorous and sufficiently complete to communicate the main findings without reproducing every technical detail.
b) Project description and location
The EIA identifies the project, its stage, the proponent, the permitting authority and the people responsible for preparing the EIA. It describes the project’s purpose, need, alternatives, associated infrastructure, and the estimated construction, operation and decommissioning schedule.
For each alternative, it should describe and quantify, as relevant, the materials and energy used or produced; expected effluents, waste and emissions to water, soil and air; and sources and levels of noise, vibration, light, heat or radiation. Location information should include suitable maps, relevant sensitive areas, applicable land-use plans and restrictions, and potentially affected infrastructure.
4. Baseline environmental conditions
The baseline describes the current state of the environment that may be significantly affected, as well as its likely evolution in the absence of the project. It covers:
| Dimension | Typical factors |
|---|---|
| Natural environment | Biodiversity, including fauna and flora; soil; water; atmosphere; landscape; climate; mineral resources. |
| Social and economic environment | Population and settlement; cultural heritage; restrictions and easements; infrastructure and networks; planned land uses; socioeconomic conditions. |
The methods used to establish the baseline must be explained. The assessment requires interdisciplinary work: specialists must integrate their contributions around the shared assessment problem, rather than simply placing separate discipline reports side by side. The methods selected depend chiefly on the project’s scale and the sensitivity of its location.
5. Portuguese EIA decision and follow-up
In Portugal, the EIA decision is set out in the Environmental Impact Statement (DIA). It may be favourable, conditionally favourable or unfavourable; an unfavourable decision must state its reasons. A favourable or conditional decision may include conditions, and a conditional DIA must specify the conditions for authorisation and the mitigation measures the proponent must implement. The DIA must also explain why repeatedly raised public-consultation suggestions were not accepted.
After a favourable or conditionally favourable DIA, the EIA Authority directs post-assessment across the project’s authorisation, construction, operation and decommissioning. It checks compliance with the DIA, evaluates the effectiveness of the EIA process and its mitigation or enhancement measures, and determines whether new measures are needed. Audits and monitoring support this work.
When the EIA was conducted at preliminary-design or draft-project stage, the proponent must submit the final execution project with a RECAPE (Environmental Compliance Report for the Execution Project). The RECAPE demonstrates that the execution project complies with the DIA; it is not a new EIA. Its purposes are to ensure implementation of DIA measures through project design and management systems, study identified issues in greater detail, present monitoring programmes, and verify that predicted impact significance has not changed and that no new impacts have arisen.
Alternatives, Mitigation and Monitoring in EIA
1. Baseline conditions
The baseline describes the environment affected by the project and must support the analysis of the project’s impacts and alternatives. Its level of detail should be proportional to the potential significance of impacts: less important information can be summarized, consolidated, or referenced. The overall uncertainty in the baseline must be stated, taking account of the environmental factors used.
| Approach | How descriptors are selected and handled |
|---|---|
| Systematic | Includes all descriptor groups without differentiating how information is treated. |
| Focused | Selects the main descriptor groups according to the project’s potential impacts. |
| Mixed | Includes a broad set of descriptors but gives them different levels of attention. |
Potential baseline descriptors include topography, climate, geology, land use, soils, flora and fauna, hydrology, landscape, environmental quality, air and water quality, noise, socio-economics, cultural heritage, and project-specific factors such as coastal dynamics, currents, traffic, and archaeology.
Sub-descriptors are selected according to their environmental, conservation, economic, social, or public relevance; the information available or obtainable; the degree to which the project may affect them; their usefulness for predicting impacts; and their relevance to monitoring.
Baseline information may come from literature, experts and relevant organizations, surveys of local residents, field observation of habitats and landscape units, and sampling campaigns or surveys. Sampling is often constrained by limited time and funding; results may depend on sampling method and size, season, habitat, time of day, and weather conditions.
2. Impact assessment in EIA
An environmental impact is a change in an environmental parameter, in a defined area and period, caused by human action, compared with what would occur without that action. Some approaches distinguish cause (human action), effect (environmental change), and impact (the consequence of that change).
Impact assessment identifies significant impacts for each alternative, classifies them, and evaluates their significance using defined scales and prediction methods. It must consider impacts arising from the project’s presence, use of energy and natural resources, emissions, and waste or effluent disposal. It must identify both positive and negative impacts, as well as environmental risks, including accident risks and proposed prevention measures.
| Classification dimension | Categories |
|---|---|
| Incidence | Direct or indirect |
| Probability | Certain, probable, or uncertain |
| Duration | Permanent or temporary |
| Timing | Immediate, medium-term, or long-term |
| Spatial extent | Adjacent, regional, or transboundary |
| Reversibility | Reversible or irreversible |
| Cumulative character | Simple or cumulative |
| Importance | Positive, negligible, or negative |
Assessment must state the uncertainty in impact identification and prediction, the methods and scientific basis used, and the criteria for judging significance. Cumulative and synergistic impacts are assessed in combination with other existing or planned projects, including associated or subsidiary projects.
Compare all alternatives and identify the environmentally preferable one, explaining the criteria used.
The comparison may consider location, technology, energy use, raw materials, project size, and design. The EIA must also describe measures to avoid, reduce, or compensate for negative impacts and to enhance positive ones, and identify impacts that cannot be avoided, minimized, or compensated, as well as irreversible resource use.
3. Impact identification methods
EIA methods support three tasks: identify and classify impacts, evaluate them, and recommend mitigation measures.
| Method | Main use | Key advantage | Main limitation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ad hoc expert assessment | Expert review of the project and affected environment; often combined with checklists. | Can be tailored to the specific case. | May fail to identify some impacts. |
| Checklists | Structured lists of impacts, often organized by topic; may use questions answered “Yes,” “No,” or “Unknown.” | Provides a structured approach to identifying impacts and key environmental factors. | Can overlook impacts not on the list and makes cross-disciplinary links difficult. |
| Matrices | Links project actions or phases (rows) to impacts (columns), sometimes including classification and evaluation. | Clearly connects impacts to the project actions that cause them. | Can be complex to interpret. |
| Cause–effect flowcharts | Traces chains of effects from project actions through environmental descriptors. | Helps identify indirect and higher-order impacts, integrate disciplines, and assess cumulative effects. | Diagrams can become complex; impact classification is difficult to incorporate. |
| Database overlays | Combines thematic databases with maps of the project area. | Supports spatial analysis using mapped environmental information. | Requires suitable thematic data and cartography. |
Overlay themes may include topography, land use, aquatic systems and groundwater, habitat types, and dynamic circulation models.
Environmental Factors and Indicators in EIA
1. Environmental factors considered in an EIA
Environmental factors are the components of the environment that may be affected by a project. They are described using indicators—measurable or otherwise identifiable characteristics that help establish baseline conditions, predict impacts and monitor change.
| Category | Factors and examples of indicators |
|---|---|
| Physical environment | Climate: air temperature, precipitation, relative humidity, wind regime and thunderstorms. Geology and geomorphology: geological setting, seismicity and tectonics, volcanism, geological resources, terrain relief and morphology. Soils: soil characteristics. Water resources: hydrographic setting, flows, groundwater aquifers and water uses. |
| Environmental quality | Noise, air quality, soil quality, water quality, waste and light pollution. |
| Ecology and landscape | Landscape, flora, fauna, species distribution by habitat and species with conservation status. |
| Land use and planning | Land use, interference with environmentally sensitive areas, planning restrictions and infrastructure-related constraints. |
| Socio-economics and heritage | Population and demographics, families, education, employment, wages and working conditions, living conditions, social protection, health, knowledge and information, justice, culture and leisure; historical, archaeological, architectural and cultural heritage. |
2. How environmental factors are used
The description of each factor establishes the baseline situation against which project-related change can be assessed. Indicators should be relevant to the project, its location and its likely impacts. For example, climate is characterised using variables such as temperature and precipitation, while water resources may be described through flows, aquifers and existing uses.
Physical-environment factors are commonly included in EIAs, but significant impacts are often not identified and these factors are not usually subject to post-assessment monitoring. Land-use and planning factors are also frequently considered, though they are usually not monitored after assessment. Socio-economic factors can be examined at different geographical and time scales, but are often treated superficially.
Indicators connect the baseline description of an environmental factor to impact assessment and, where appropriate, project monitoring.
3. Mapping environmental information
Thematic mapping can help identify areas that are important for different environmental factors and reveal potential conflicts. Graphical representation also makes EIA information easier to interpret. However, this approach is not widely used because thematic databases may be unavailable or difficult to obtain, mapping can be time-consuming, and maps alone do not assess impacts.
Generic Environmental Impacts of Projects: Planning and Construction
1. Socio-economic factors
Economic and social indicators help describe the baseline conditions and assess project effects on people and economic activity.
| Indicator class | Examples |
|---|---|
| Economic activity | Economic sectors, companies |
| Economic performance | Gross Domestic Product (GDP), Gross Value Added (GVA) |
| Demand and trade | Consumption, investment, balance of goods and services |
| Labour market | Employment, unemployment, activity rate |
| Prices | Price indices |
2. Heritage
Heritage assessment covers officially classified heritage and assets under consideration for classification, archaeological sites (whether classified or not), and potentially significant unclassified assets. The impact assessment evaluates the magnitude of project effects on each identified asset.
Where there is strong evidence of archaeological remains, geophysical survey campaigns and archaeological test excavations may be undertaken. A specialist may also need to monitor construction works. Heritage monitoring is generally uncommon outside the construction phase; assessments have historically been limited and may remain preliminary.
3. Environmental quality and health
Environmental-quality assessment commonly addresses factors relevant to human health:
- Noise (acoustic environment)
- Air quality
- Water quality
- Soil quality
- Waste management
- Light pollution
These topics are widely included in Environmental Impact Assessments (EIAs), but impacts are often difficult to predict precisely. Links with biological components are rarely assessed, reflecting a predominantly human-centred approach. Post-assessment may be undertaken depending on the project, its emissions, and proximity to population centres.
a) Noise
Under Portugal’s General Noise Regulation, Decree-Law No. 292/2000 of 14 November 2000, continuous equivalent sound levels () must not exceed:
| Zone | Day: 07:00–22:00 | Night: 22:00–07:00 |
|---|---|---|
| Sensitive | 55 dB(A) | 45 dB(A) |
| Mixed | 65 dB(A) | 55 dB(A) |
Municipal councils classify sensitive and mixed zones, which must be delimited in the relevant Municipal Land-Use Plan. Assessment typically combines in-situ sound-level measurements, appropriate sampling and meteorological conditions, noise-intensity maps, and reference values. Noise levels are often difficult to predict accurately.
b) Air quality
- Limit value: maximum concentration of an atmospheric pollutant in the receiving environment that must not be exceeded over specified periods, to protect human health and the environment.
- Guide value: reference concentration used to establish specific regimes in certain areas, with a sufficient long-term safety margin for health, population well-being, and environmental quality.
Commonly assessed parameters include ozone, SO₂, NO, NO₂, CO, CO₂, total suspended particles (TSP), and heavy metals. Where emissions are released from a defined source such as a chimney, pollutant dispersion can often be predicted with some accuracy.
Assessment methods include nearby monitoring-program data, in-situ measurements, modelling, and bioindicators.
c) Water and soil quality
Water-quality assessment may use nearby monitoring data, in-situ measurements, models, bioindicators, and ecological water-quality assessment. Effects are often difficult to predict precisely, and post-assessment may be required depending on the project and proponent.
Soil quality is less often assessed as a standalone topic. Its impacts are also difficult to predict, links to biological components are uncommon, and post-assessment is rare.
d) Waste management and light pollution
Waste assessment should describe existing waste production and disposal in the study area, forecast project-generated waste, identify suitable destinations and links to regional infrastructure (including information from Municipal Land-Use Plans), and consider the legislation applicable to each waste type.
Light pollution has only recently begun to be treated as a separate assessment factor. It is usually considered from a human-centred perspective, though it may sometimes be assessed ecologically.
4. Landscape
Landscape is the overall, dynamic and evolving image of a territorial area, formed by interacting ecosystems that recur across it in similar ways. Landscape assessment is common in EIAs but can be subjective; it is not usually subject to post-assessment.
a) Landscape units and assessment
A landscape unit (LU) is an area relatively homogeneous in relief, geology, and human use (including agricultural and forest use), producing a broadly similar visual perception.
Assessment typically involves field surveys and photographs to cover the study area, defining LUs, selecting criteria to value them, and comparing project elements and alternatives to identify landscape changes and mitigation measures.
| Criterion | What it considers | Higher landscape value is associated with |
|---|---|---|
| Form | Relief and visually significant features, including geological features | Diverse landforms, greater scale and elevation contrast, and prominent distinctive features |
| Vegetation | Variety, distribution, density, and contrast of vegetation strata, forms, and colours | Greater diversity, alternation, and balanced contrasts |
| Humanisation | Distribution of human activities and structures in relation to the biophysical setting | A harmonious relationship with the setting and the presence of important structural or heritage features |
| Visibility | Ease of viewing, influenced by accessibility, relief, and visual catchment | Greater access, more viewpoints, and wider, deeper views |
Two additional concepts inform landscape sensitivity:
- Visual fragility: susceptibility to change when land use is altered.
- Visual absorption capacity: the ability to incorporate modifications without reducing the landscape’s visual qualities.
Landscape cause-and-effect relationships can be speculative and difficult to substantiate. The specific subtopics assessed depend on the project.
5. Flora and fauna
Evidence on flora and fauna may come from general and specialist literature, interviews with local residents, experts and relevant organisations, habitat observation, and direct observation or detection of organisms and their traces.
A typical assessment sequence is:
- Identify species potentially present in the study area using literature and expert input.
- Visit the area to observe habitats, detect organisms, and interview local residents.
- Assess the value of species present and identify priority species.
- Characterise the area’s communities and habitats from a flora and fauna perspective.
- Determine the area’s importance for fisheries and hunting.
Environmental Impacts of Roads and Railways
1. Legal protection of flora, fauna and habitats
Environmental assessment should identify sensitive areas and species within the study area. Key international and European instruments include:
| Instrument | Main purpose |
|---|---|
| Bern Convention (82/72/EEC) | International cooperation to protect wild flora and fauna and their natural habitats. |
| Bonn Convention (82/461/EEC) | Protection of migratory species through coordinated, cross-border action. |
| CITES (3626/82) | Regulates international trade in endangered species through a licensing system; trade in most listed species is prohibited. |
| Birds Directive (79/409/EEC) | Protects threatened European bird species and their habitats. |
| Habitats Directive (92/43/EEC) | Conserves natural habitats and wild fauna (excluding birds) and flora. |
| Natura Network | Classified sites where nature conservation is a priority. |
The Portuguese Red Data Book of Vertebrates (2005) records expert assessments of the conservation status of vertebrate populations found in Portugal. Species are assigned one of eight categories based on IUCN (2001) criteria.
Other instruments used to identify or protect sites and habitats include protected areas, Natura sites, Habitats Directive Annex I sites, wetlands covered by the Ramsar Convention, and Portugal’s National Ecological Reserve (Decree-Law 93/90, 19 March), National Agricultural Reserve (Decree-Law 451/82, 16 November) and Public Water Domain (Decree-Law 468/71, 5 November).
2. Flora and habitat surveys
The common approach to habitat inventory is to define landscape units, complemented by botanical surveys.
| Survey method | Typical application |
|---|---|
| Transects | Trees and shrubs; also used in intertidal and subtidal zones, often with percentage-cover estimates. |
| Quadrats | All vegetation layers, especially herbaceous vegetation. |
Flora baseline surveys may also use relative-abundance and phytosociological indices.
3. Fauna survey methods
Survey methods should match the organisms and habitats being studied.
| Group or environment | Common methods |
|---|---|
| Terrestrial invertebrates | Pitfall traps for ground-moving insects; window, funnel or sticky traps for flying insects; beating nets for insects on plants. |
| Freshwater aquatic invertebrates | D-shaped or screen nets. |
| Brackish or marine invertebrates | Beam trawls for decapods; plankton nets for phyto-, zoo- and ichthyoplankton; dredges or sediment samplers for benthic organisms in mobile substrates; scraping for hard, rocky substrates. |
| Fish | Direct observation (diving, video, photography); capture using appropriate fishing methods; population interviews; expert and literature consultation. |
| Amphibians | Day and night searches, aquatic-net sampling, listening for calls (usually at night), trapping, interviews and literature or expert consultation. |
| Reptiles | Day and night searches in suitable habitats, distant observation with binoculars, interviews and literature or expert consultation. |
| Birds | Transects, fixed-point and strategic counts; call surveys; capture; signs; radar detection in flight; interviews and literature or expert consultation. |
| Mammals | Transects and fixed-point observations; aerial or maritime surveys; signs (especially tracks and droppings); trapping; analysis of raptor pellets; call surveys, interviews and literature or expert consultation. |
4. Minimising impacts and monitoring
Mitigation requires identifying priority species and sensitive areas, then combining project-action information with species’ life-history patterns and habitat use. Activities should be planned appropriately in space and time to reduce disturbance. Monitoring is commonly used to track environmental effects and the effectiveness of mitigation.
Environmental Impacts of Airports
1. Airport project phases
Airport construction generates impacts similar to those of roads and railways: land clearing, earthworks, temporary construction sites and access roads, machinery use, material transport, and potential spills or pollution. During operation, the main impact-generating activities are the presence of airport infrastructure and access routes, aircraft movements, increased accessibility, and runway maintenance and repair.
2. Main environmental impacts
| Impact area | Key effects |
|---|---|
| Noise and public health | Aircraft noise affects nearby populations. |
| Air pollution and climate change | Aircraft and associated ground activities emit pollutants; air traffic also contributes to climate change. |
| Water and soil | Accidental spills can contaminate water and soil; airport runoff may also be a concern. |
| Land and landscape | Earthworks can alter the landscape and land use. |
| Energy and waste | Airport operations require energy and generate waste that must be managed. |
| Biodiversity and heritage | Impacts may affect fauna, flora, landscape, and heritage. |
During construction, the main pressures are earthworks and resulting changes to the landscape and land use, accidental releases of pollutants, atmospheric emissions and dust, and increased noise.
3. Noise measurement: DNL
DNL (Day-Night Average Sound Level) represents a person’s cumulative sound exposure over 24 hours. It is expressed as the noise level for an average day of the year, based on annual aircraft operations, providing a consistent way to describe environmental noise.
A small number of relatively loud operations can produce the same DNL as a large number of relatively quiet operations.
4. Aircraft emissions during operation
The ICAO LTO cycle covers the local-scale aircraft operations of take-off, landing, and taxiing. Airport-related emissions also arise from ground activities, including engine ignition, auxiliary power units (APUs), airside traffic, infrastructure and maintenance, aircraft maintenance, and induced landside traffic. Cruise emissions occur at a global scale.
5. Minimising construction impacts
Key measures include:
- Schedule work appropriately to reduce disturbance to the environment and local populations.
- Apply appropriate worker-safety practices.
- Arrange archaeological monitoring where necessary.
- Use local labour.
Environmental Impacts of Ports and Marine Projects
1. Project types and impact drivers
The environmental effects of ports and other marine or coastal projects depend on the project’s type, location, scale, and the local characteristics of the affected environmental component.
| Project types |
|---|
| Marinas and ports; navigation channels and port-access maintenance |
| Shipyards and coastal land reclamation |
| Beach nourishment and coastal protection |
| Outfalls and oil or gas pipelines |
| Bridges and other marine infrastructure |
2. Main impact-generating activities
| Phase | Main activities |
|---|---|
| Construction | Reclaiming marine areas; installing marine and coastal infrastructure; dredging and disposing of dredged material; operating construction sites and machinery; building temporary access routes; workers’ activities; transporting construction materials and waste |
| Operation | Presence of infrastructure and associated changes; operation and maintenance of navigation channels; vessel traffic and noise; routine or accidental pollutant releases; ballast-water intake and discharge; keeping vessel surfaces free of living organisms |
3. Main environmental impacts
Habitats and coastal processes may be lost or altered. Infrastructure and dredging can change water circulation and sediment deposition, increase turbidity, and generate shock waves.
Water and sediment quality can be affected by pollution, including the resuspension of contaminants already present in sediments. Other concerns include increased eutrophication, reduced light penetration into the water (a smaller photic zone), pollutants discharged by vessels, and hydrocarbon accumulation.
| Environmental component | Key impacts |
|---|---|
| Aquatic biota | Direct mortality; physiological and behavioural changes; displacement; decline or loss of sensitive species; increase in tolerant or opportunistic species; introduction of non-native species; pollutant bioaccumulation |
| Coastal landscape | Changes to the landscape value of the coastal area |
| Socio-economy | Displacement of settlements; conflicts between coastal uses; cultural change; economic development, employment, a wider range of economic activities, and tourism |
4. Mitigation measures
| Impact area | Main measures |
|---|---|
| Hydrology, sediments, water quality | Isolate the dredging area; select appropriate dredging equipment, sites, and periods; dispose of dredged material according to its contamination level; use barriers to limit airborne sediment dispersal; apply good maritime-traffic practices and accident-prevention and response systems |
| Biota | Choose suitable locations, seasons, times of day, and tidal conditions for construction and maintenance; select appropriate dredging equipment; assess sediment contamination and manage it accordingly; select suitable disposal locations and conditions; use non-toxic paints and materials; follow maritime-transport regulations and good practice |
| Landscape | Seek better landscape-design solutions |
| Socio-economy | Seek solutions that make coastal activities compatible with social, cultural, and economic uses |
Dredging requires control of both sediment disturbance and disposal: assess contamination, choose suitable methods and timing, and manage the material accordingly.
5. Dredged-material contamination classes
Under Portuguese Portaria No. 450/2007, following the Joint Order of the Ministries of Environment and the Sea dated 4 April 1995, dredged materials are classified by contaminant concentration. Values below are in mg/kg; class boundaries are shown as given in the source.
| Contaminant | Class 1 | Class 2 | Class 3 | Class 4 | Class 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lead (Pb) | – | – | – | ||
| Nickel (Ni) | – | – | – | ||
| Zinc (Zn) | – | – | – | ||
| Mercury (Hg) | – | – | – | ||
| Copper (Cu) | – | – | – | ||
| Cadmium (Cd) | – | – | – | ||
| Arsenic (As) | – | – | – | ||
| Chromium (Cr) | – | – | – | ||
| Hexachlorobenzene | – | – | – | ||
| Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (sum) | – | – | – | ||
| PCBs (sum) | – | – | – |